August 20, 2024 Conquering Manufacturing Compliance: ITAR vs. EAR

Identifying the differences between International Traffic in Arms Regulations & Export Administration Regulations is key for compliance.

By Cormac Twomey, CTO at Envoy

Navigating compliance is a challenging endeavor for manufacturers, and it’s easy to see why. On average, the U.S. has enacted one new manufacturing-related law per week since 1981.  This complexity extends to key regulations, including the International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR) and the Export Administration Regulations (EAR). These compliance standards aim to protect national security by regulating the export of items with potential military or strategic significance. For manufacturers across industries, compliance is non-negotiable, and with recent updates to ITAR and EAR, a solid understanding of these regulations, including the nuances that set them apart, is critical for success.

Defining ITAR and EAR

ITAR is a set of U.S. regulations that govern the export and import of defense-related services and technologies. Compliance requires the implementation of stringent access control measures and registration with the Directorate of Defense Trade Controls (DDTC) to ensure that ITAR data in the cloud is not accessed by foreign entities. If an organization deals with items on the United States Munitions List (USML), compliance is mandatory. Specific industries that must comply with ITAR include:

• Defense and aerospace. Companies that manufacture and supply military equipment, defense systems, and aircraft.
• Technology. Companies providing or developing technologies and software related to military or defense applications.
• Engineering and manufacturing. Companies producing components or systems that are used in the defense and aerospace industries.
• Research and development. Companies engaged in research for military or defense technologies.
• Export and logistics. Companies involved in the shipment, export, or transport of defense-related items and services.

While EAR is also a set of U.S. government regulations, it focuses on guidelines around the export and re-export of commercial and dual-use items with both commercial and potential military applications. EAR aims to ensure that the goods in these classifications do not compromise national security or foreign policy interests. The Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) administers these regulations for the following industries:

• Technology and electronics. Companies exporting computer software, hardware, and telecommunications equipment.
• Aerospace and aviation. Companies working with aircraft parts and navigation systems.
• Chemical and biological products. Companies manufacturing biological agents or chemicals with potential dual-use applications.
• Engineering and manufacturing. Companies producing machinery or industrial equipment.
• Research and development. Companies developing innovative technologies with potential dual-use applications.

Highlighting the Differences

ITAR and EAR both aim to protect national security by regulating the export of items with strategic or military significance, and these regulations are pivotal for organizations working in the above areas. However, ITAR and EAR also differ in a variety of ways:

Regulatory bodies and licensing requirements.

• ITAR: Administered by the DDTC, a division of the U.S. Department of State. Companies must obtain an export license to transfer any defense-related articles, services, and technical data listed on the USML. To get a license, exporters must submit an application to the DDTC.
• EAR: Administered by the BIS, a division of the U.S. Department of Commerce. The licensing process for EAR involves determining an item’s Export Control Classification Numbers (ECCNs), destination country, end user, and use case. Exporters must submit a license application to the BIS, which evaluates it based on specific criteria: national security, foreign policy, and proliferation concerns.

Types of items.

• ITAR: Controls military items such as ammunition, firearms, and other defense articles.
• EAR: Covers commercial products with potential military use, such as certain software, electronics, and chemicals.

Classification systems.

• ITAR: Leverages 21 categories on the United States Munitions List.
• EAR: Utilizes ECCNS listed on the  Commerce Control List (CCL).

Fines and penalties.

• ITAR: Violations can result in civil fines up to $500,000 per violation, criminal fines up to $1,000,000 and 10 years imprisonment per violation.
• EAR: Violations can lead to criminal penalties of up to 20 years imprisonment and $1,000,000 in fines per violation, or administrative penalties reaching $300,000 per violation.

Maintaining ITAR and EAR Compliance with a Visitor Management System

Compliance management is not a cut-and-dry process, and it requires innovative solutions—like a visitor management system (VMS)—to ensure the necessary regulatory requirements are met. These systems help ensure compliance by cross-checking visitor information against restricted lists. If individuals are known risks or have previously violated export controls, a VMS can ensure that they are denied entry. ITAR, for example, prohibits access to foreign nationals unless they have been specifically authorized.

Visitor management systems can also streamline the check-in process, gather necessary guest information, and manage legal documentation, such as non-disclosure agreements. As a result, organizations can easily create an auditable trail of visitor activity (another regulatory requirement).

For manufacturers, maintaining compliance with ITAR and EAR is about more than just understanding how they differ. It’s also about instituting the security measures and visitor policies that ensure organizations avoid violations and the headaches they produce. The right visitor management solution can help with that.

Cormac is the Chief Technology Officer at Envoy with over 25 years of experience in software engineering and architecture. His passion is to invest in product development teams and empower them to achieve accelerated velocity and quality for the organization.

Subscribe to Industry Today